Band-in-a-Box Vs. AI-Powered Vocal/Instrumental Remover: What’s better?

Choosing the perfect musicians tool: Band-in-a-Box or a vocal/split track remover? Can AI create a backing track in the style of an existing song?

Band-in-a-Box and the split track remover with AI are two different tools used in music production, and they serve distinct purposes.

Here’s an overview of the differences between them:


Band-in-a-Box is a software application developed by PG Music that provides musicians and composers with a virtual backing band. It is primarily used for creating accompaniment tracks for practice, performance, or songwriting.

The software allows users to input chord progressions, choose musical styles, and generate full arrangements with various instrument tracks, including drums, bass, guitar, piano, and more. Band-in-a-Box is designed to assist musicians in quickly generating realistic-sounding backing tracks in different genres.

AI Vocal/Split Remover

Vocal/split track remover  is a tool that utilizes artificial intelligence algorithms to separate different elements within an audio track, such as isolating vocals from a mixed song or removing vocals to extract instrumental tracks.

It leverages machine learning techniques to analyze the audio waveform and identify and separate different components based on their characteristics, such as frequency content, stereo panning, and spatial properties.

The goal of this tool is to provide users with the ability to manipulate and remix audio tracks by isolating or removing specific elements, such as vocals or instruments.

Can AI create a backing track in the style of an existing song?

 There are several approaches to do this:

AI can be used to analyze an existing song and separate musical elements, such as the bass line, drums or guitar parts. Once extracted, these elements can be manipulated and used to create a new backing track, maintaining the style and feel of the original song.

However, it’s important to note that AI may not be able to exactly replicate the style and quality of an existing song. The processing and generation of musical elements can be influenced by many factors, and the output can vary based on the complexity of the reference song and the quality of the AI used.

What is better, BiaB or Track Remover?

Ultimately, the “better” choice depends on your specific goals and use case. If you are primarily focused on creating full arrangements and backing tracks, an music generator like Band-in-a-Box might be more suitable.

On the other hand, if your priority is isolating vocals or specific instruments from existing tracks for remixing or study purposes, an AI vocal/track remover would be the better choice.


In summary, Band-in-a-Box focuses on generating complete backing tracks for musical accompaniment, while vocal/split remover  aims to separate or extract specific elements from an existing audio track, such as vocals or instruments.

Both tools have different applications and cater to different needs in music production and composition.




Discover the latest musical instruments on our music website on Amazon!

Explore the latest musical instruments on Amazon music store and support our channel at no extra cost to you! By purchasing any musical instrument through our affiliate link, you not only get top-quality gear but also contribute to our channel's growth and content creation.

SGU BackingTracks


Join our Telegram group: Band in a Box Backing Tracks. 


Join our Facebook group (download/share backing tracks): SGU BackingTracks

Author: GiancarloG

One-Man-Band guitar player with self-composed backing tracks using Band-in-a-Box RealTracks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Translate »